英文摘要 Abstract
PURPOSE: To evaluate the change in hip distractive stability after a cam over-resection, labral tear, repair, labrectomy, or circumferential 6- or 10-mm labral reconstruction in a biomechanical model.
METHODS: Ten fresh-frozen matched-pair human cadaveric hips were analyzed using a materials testing system to measure the force and distance required to disrupt the suction seal of the hip (1) with an intact capsule and labrum; (2) after a capsulectomy and labral repair; (3) after a capsulectomy, 5-mm cam over-resection and labral repair; (4) after a capsulectomy, 5-mm cam over-resection and labral tear; (5) after a capsulectomy, 5-mm cam over-resection and labrectomy; and (6) after a capsulectomy, 5-mm cam over-resection and a 6- or 10-mm circumferential labral reconstruction with iliotibial band (5 hips each). Each specimen was retested at 0° flexion, 45° flexion, and 45° flexion and at 15° internal rotation and analyzed using nonparametric statistical methods.
RESULTS: The Friedman test of differences was significant among structural conditions and hip positions (P = .001). In all positions, the resistive force that opposed the disruption of the suction seal in an intact hip was significantly greater compared with all other conditions. The resistive force for the capsulectomy, 5-mm cam over-resection and labrectomy condition was significantly less compared with almost all other conditions and hip positions. A qualitative suction seal was achieved in 20% of hip specimens with a 6-mm labral reconstruction, whereas a seal was in achieved 60% of specimens with a 10-mm labral reconstruction.
CONCLUSIONS: After a cam over-resection, a circumferential labral reconstruction improves the distractive stability of a labral deficient hip, comparable to a labral repair or tear in a biomechanical model.
CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Circumferential labral reconstruction may be a viable treatment option for patients with ongoing symptoms after hip arthroscopy with evidence of a cam over-res
中文总结
该研究采用10具新鲜冷冻配对尸体髋关节标本,通过材料测试系统评估了cam过度切除后不同盂唇处理方式对髋关节牵拉稳定性的影响,测试条件包括完整关节囊、关节囊切除加盂唇修复、cam过度切除5毫米加盂唇修复、cam过度切除加盂唇撕裂、cam过度切除加盂唇切除以及6毫米或10毫米环形盂唇重建各5髋。结果显示,完整髋关节的密封圈抗破坏力显著高于其他所有条件,而盂唇切除后抗破坏力最低;10毫米环形盂唇重建在60%的标本中恢复了密封圈,而6毫米重建仅20%。该研究提示,对于cam过度切除导致的盂唇缺损,环形盂唇重建是一种可行的修复选择,较宽移植物能更好地恢复关节稳定性,这对翻修手术中恢复关节密封功能具有重要指导意义。
英文摘要 Abstract
Hip arthroscopy technique and innovation has revolutionized the surgical approach to femoroacetabular impingement syndrome (FAIS). Arthroscopic labral reconstruction is the gold-standard treatment for irreparable acetabular labral tears in FAIS surgery and backed by robust long-term clinical data. However, cam over-resection has become a prevalent complication, often co-occurring with irreparable labral tears in revision FAIS surgery. Revision circumferential labral reconstruction is a promising solution, particularly from a biomechanical perspective, in restoring the suction seal. Larger graft width is indicated in these cases.
中文总结
这篇述评针对髋关节镜翻修手术中cam过度切除合并不可修复盂唇撕裂这一常见并发症进行了深入讨论。作者指出,关节镜下盂唇重建已成为股骨髋臼撞击综合征手术中不可修复盂唇撕裂的金标准治疗,但cam过度切除在翻修手术中日益普遍,常与不可修复盂唇撕裂同时出现。从生物力学角度,环形盂唇重建是恢复关节密封圈功能的有效方案,尤其需要使用较宽移植物(10毫米)以获得更好的稳定性,较窄移植物仅在20%的标本中恢复密封圈,而10毫米移植物在60%中恢复。该述评提醒临床医生,在翻修手术中应充分评估cam切除程度,对于合并盂唇缺损的病例,选择足够宽度的移植物进行环形重建是优化手术效果的关键策略。